
By Simon Osamoh, CEO, Kingswood Security
Originally published in Worship Facility magazine, November 2024. Updated for Simon Speaks Security.
Summary: A trusted church administrator stole more than $330,000 over two years before anyone noticed. Her case shows why trust is not a financial control, and what every nonprofit, church, school, and small business can do to close the gaps.
The person most likely to steal from your organization is someone you already trust.
Most organizations think about security in terms of doors, cameras, and people walking in from outside. Financial theft usually comes from the inside, from a staff member or volunteer who has been given access and then left alone with it. If you want to prevent embezzlement, the work starts with how money moves through your organization and who can move it without anyone else seeing.
Case study: $330,000 taken from a church organization
In November 2024, Kaitlyn Fisher, a 31-year-old former administrative executive assistant for The Presbytery of Kendall in Idaho Falls, Idaho, was sentenced to three to ten years in prison for embezzling more than $330,000. The theft took place over two years and did serious damage to the organization.
Fisher initially faced 15 felony charges, including grand theft, tax evasion, perjury, and computer fraud. A plea agreement reduced those to grand theft, tax evasion, and perjury. Her defense said the money was used to cover urgent family medical expenses and other hardships, including her husband’s job loss and lack of insurance. According to her attorney, about $100,000 went toward legitimate medical bills.
The scheme came apart when financial discrepancies surfaced during a review and investigators traced unauthorized transactions back to her. The core problem was simple: there were no effective internal controls, so one person could exploit the system unchecked for a long time.
A similar pattern played out at Christ the King Catholic Church in Tampa, where a former records and finance manager admitted to taking about $775,000. She destroyed signed vendor checks and replaced them with handwritten checks payable to herself. That theft was uncovered by an audit.
What’s the lesson?
Trust alone is not a financial control. In both cases, one person had enough access to create, approve, and hide transactions. Good people under financial pressure make bad decisions, and a system that depends on everyone always being honest will eventually fail.
This is not a church problem. Any organization with a small finance team, a long-tenured bookkeeper, or volunteers handling cash has the same exposure. Nonprofits, schools, associations, and small businesses often run lean and rely on goodwill, which is exactly the environment where embezzlement goes unnoticed.
What we’re seeing at Kingswood
In assessments, we often find that one person opens the mail, deposits the checks, enters the transactions, and reconciles the bank statement. Leaders are usually surprised when we map it out, because that person is almost always well liked and has been there for years. We also see background checks done once at hire and never again, and no clear way for staff to raise a concern about money without going through the very person they are worried about. When something does look wrong, an organization needs facts before it makes accusations, which is where independent employee investigations and background checks become essential.
How can your organization prevent embezzlement?
- Use dual controls and separate duties. Require two unrelated people to sign checks, approve payroll, or access accounts. Split the work so one person handles incoming funds, another keeps the books, and a third approves disbursements, and rotate duties where you can.
- Bring in an independent audit. Have a third-party professional with nonprofit experience review your finances annually or every other year. Share the results with your board and members to build trust.
- Vet people who handle money, and keep vetting them. Run background checks on all staff and volunteers with financial access before they start, repeat them every few years, and explain openly that this is standard practice.
- Write it down and train on it. Create a financial handbook covering cash handling, expense approvals, and reimbursements. Train on it every year, use real cases as examples, and give people a safe, anonymous way to report concerns.
Frequently asked questions
Common signs include one person controlling an entire financial process, reluctance to take time off or share duties, missing or altered records, and bank reconciliations that are late or never reviewed. None of these prove theft, but each one is a gap worth closing.
Yes. Small organizations are often the most exposed because duties are concentrated in a few people. An independent reviewer sees what an internal team has stopped noticing, and the knowledge that an audit is coming is itself a deterrent.
Do not confront the person or start digging through records on your own. Preserve documents, limit who knows, and bring in legal counsel and a licensed investigator so the facts are gathered properly and can hold up later.
About Simon Osamoh
Simon Osamoh is the founder and CEO of Kingswood Security, a Minneapolis-based risk management firm that has served clients in more than 16 states since 2014. He is the former head of counterterrorism at Mall of America and regularly provides security commentary to national media, including CBS News. Kingswood Security Consulting, LLC is licensed in Minnesota as a private detective agency (License No. 2498) and protective agent agency (License No. 2497).
If your organization has one person who controls the money, schedule a confidential consultation with Kingswood using the form below.
Sources: East Idaho News; The Christian Post
Work With Kingswood
Request a Consultation
Have a question about something in this episode, or a situation you are facing now? Tell us a little about yourself and a member of the Kingswood team will reach out within one business day. All inquiries are confidential.
"*" indicates required fields



